“We Need A New Anthem!”

2004 vacation 095

(Please respond to the brief polls at the end of this post.) 

In light of tomorrow’s Independence Day celebrations and after listening to several national anthems during the 2014 World Cup my resolve to see our national anthem replaced has been galvanized.  The “Star Spangled Banner” is one of the worst national anthems in the world.  It is a narrative of an obscure battle fought in a relatively obscure war that praises a flag rather than a nation.  Moreover, it is difficult to sing.  We need a new song!

We need an anthem that celebrates the diverse beauty and splendor of our country and affirms our present and future hope.

Permit me to make some comparisons with other anthems.  The Russian national anthem is musically moving and portrays the beauty and immensity of that vast nation while petitioning for divine blessing and favor.

Even the musically martial “Song of Germany” promotes hope and encouragement for the German people citing positive German attributes –  “German women, German loyalty, German wine and German song”.   It also sounds a call for unity, justice and freedom.

“Oh Canada” is arguably the best national anthem on the planet boldly praising everything that is good and unique about the Great White North while proclaiming national devotion and it achieves this with musical appeal.

“The Star Spangled Banner” derives its wartime lyrics from a poem written in 1814 by an amateur poet after witnessing a battle against the British.  Ironically, it was an English composer who wrote the music and somehow the song became our national anthem in 1931.

Please people; do we really want our global identity to be distinguished for winning a relatively insignificant battle?  Are the words “bombs bursting in air” what we want sung in front of the rest of the world when our Olympic gold medalists stand proudly on a pedestal?  Is the line “rockets red glare” really an appropriate precursor to the celebrated cry to “Play Ball”?

In America, we enjoy a selection of songs from which a more appropriate anthem can be chosen including “America The Beautiful” and “God Bless America”.  “My Country ‘Tis of Thee” would serve as an acceptable replacement except for sharing a musical score with “God Save The Queen”, the National Anthem of England.

In any case, our current anthem is severely wanting and a change is long overdue.  Let us introduce a new anthem for our beloved United States of America.

In future posts I will address the case in favor of  “America the Beautiful” and “God Bless America”.  This campaign will be a long process but “The Star Spangled Banner” is a lousy national anthem and, since our national repertoire includes significantly more suitable songs, let us employ one of them.

Whether or not you agree, please share this with others on your list… whatever that list might be.



2 thoughts on ““We Need A New Anthem!”

  1. Wow Steve, I thought I’d read the comments before I took the poll…none! So I thought maybe taking a look at the poll would give me a glimpse into the thoughts and/or idea’s others might have, maybe that’s where the reply’s were…nothing! Maybe it’s because this was only posted the day before and there hasn’t been adequate time for people to respond. Maybe people are uncomfortable about giving their opinion on such a touchy subject, or at least being the first to do so, I don’t know. I feel a bit vulnerable to be the first, but I’ll step into it with you bro…there’s that “comfort zone” thing right?

    I’ve always thought the current anthem was a difficult song to sing but the majority of americans can and do. What most people don’t realize is that there are four verses. And although the first three portray a nation built on the sacrifice and bloodshed of war, the last verse urges us to “Praise the power that hath made and preserved us a nation”. I understand that “power” to be the power given to us by God as a nation to uphold the freedoms we enjoy by opposing tyranny and opression with righteousness and sacrifice, working in conjunction with the third to the last line in verse four; “And this be our motto: ‘In God is our trust.'” In that context, the banner mentioned in the second to the last line is only representive of the trust we put in God to preserve the liberty obtained through faith and perseverence.

    But, since most people don’t know these lyrics exist because all we ever hear is the first verse, which is filled with “bombs bursting in air” and “rockets red glare”, maybe it’s time to think of something that represents the peace we seek instead of the aggression that led to it.

    1. Thanks Dave,

      You bring up a good point. I am aware that there are other verses but had forgotten about them. One nice thing about a blog post is that it is opinion. My request in the survey gave “other” as an option for an alternate anthem and perhaps one of the other verses might be appropriate.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s